News Turkish court accepts indictment of 17 people over LGBTQ+ news reports, artwork

Turkish court accepts indictment of 17 people over LGBTQ+ news reports, artwork

A Turkish court has accepted an indictment targeting 17 people, including a journalist and members of an LGBTQ+ rights group, over news reports and artwork that prosecutors deemed obscene, the Bianet news website reported.

The Ankara 27th Criminal Court of First Instance accepted the indictment on November 11, following its preparation by prosecutors on October 28. The defendants include journalist Tuğba Tekerek and members of Kaos GL, an LGBTQ+ rights organization.

The case stemmed from a nationwide crackdown on LGBTQ+ groups in September, when authorities jailed dozens of people pending trial and launched proceedings to dissolve rights associations. Five of the 17 defendants remain jailed pending trial.

Prosecutors accused the defendants of violating Turkey’s Law on Associations and Article 226 of the Turkish Penal Code, which criminalizes obscenity, alleging that content published on Kaos GL’s website and social media accounts was obscene and accessible to children.

The indictment cited 10 social media posts, including a report by Tekerek on anti-LGBTQ+ legislation in Georgia, a review of the television series “Agatha All Along,” an article about Australian athlete Campbell Harrison and posts featuring artwork, including an illustration depicting an LGBTQ+ artist’s childhood that featured a rainbow.

Kaos GL lawyer Oya Aydın said prosecutors effectively treated the publications as encouraging homosexuality among children, although Turkish law does not criminalize such conduct.

Tekerek, who has been jailed pending trial at Ankara’s Sincan Prison since September 15, was accused of administering Kaos GL’s Instagram account. She denied the accusation, saying her only connection to the organization was a freelance report she wrote during Georgia’s 2024 elections. Her lawyers previously petitioned Turkey’s Constitutional Court, saying investigators had not disclosed technical evidence supporting the accusation.

The Media and Law Studies Association (MLSA) said the indictment cited a police technical assessment but the sections made available contained no concrete digital findings establishing that Tekerek had administered the account.

Aydın also said some defendants were not serving in Kaos GL’s governing bodies when the cited material was published. She said holding association members collectively responsible for social media posts without establishing their  individual involvement violated the principle of individual criminal responsibility.

Prosecutors also cited the possibility that users could access Kaos GL’s blocked website and Instagram account through VPNs as part of their case.

Kaos GL Editor-in-Chief Yıldız Tar described the prosecution as an attempt to censor LGBTQ+ journalism, saying it treated news coverage of LGBTQ+ people as criminal activity and threatened the public’s right to access information.

Kaos GL’s lawyers said the indictment did not address a November 2016 judgment by the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) which found that Turkey had violated the organization’s freedom of expression by ordering the seizure of an issue of its magazine devoted to pornography. The court found the restriction disproportionate, saying Turkish courts had not sufficiently justified the seizure or considered less restrictive measures to protect minors.

The Ankara court also ordered the release of Kaos GL supervisory board members Selin Berghan, Burçin Kalkın and Metin Uzun under judicial supervision. It kept Tekerek and Kaos GL board members Nedime Erdoğan, Janset Kalan, Umut Derin Eroğlan and Baran Çağlar Çetinkaya jailed pending trial.

The five defendants’ pretrial detention will be reviewed on December 7, and the first hearing is scheduled for December 24.

Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan and senior officials from his ruling Justice and Development Party (AKP) have increasingly portrayed LGBTQ+ visibility as a threat to public morality and family values, while authorities have for years restricted Pride marches and publicly targeted LGBTQ+ advocacy.