News European court orders release of jailed Turkish lawmaker, says imprisonment was aimed...

European court orders release of jailed Turkish lawmaker, says imprisonment was aimed at silencing him

Erkan Baş (L), the leader of Workers' Party of Turkey (TIP) and his party's MPs Sera Kadıgil (C) and Ahmet Şık (R) display a portrait of TIP's jailed MP Can Atalay during a swearing-in ceremony at the Turkish parliament in Ankara on June 2, 2023. (Photo by Adem ALTAN / AFP)

The European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) on Tuesday ordered Turkey to immediately release jailed opposition lawmaker Can Atalay and allow him to serve in parliament, ruling that his continued imprisonment violated his rights and was intended to silence him.

The Strasbourg-based court found four violations of the European Convention on Human Rights, including the right to liberty, the right to effective judicial review of detention, the right to free elections, including his right to serve as an elected lawmaker, and the prohibition on restricting rights for improper purposes.

In a significant finding under Article 18 of the convention, the court concluded that continuing Atalay’s imprisonment without recognizing his parliamentary immunity was intended to silence him, suppress political pluralism and discourage human rights defenders from exercising their rights.

The court also found that Turkish authorities’ refusal to implement two binding Constitutional Court rulings ordering Atalay’s release had deprived him of effective judicial protection and prevented voters from being represented by their elected lawmaker.

It directed Turkey to take all necessary steps to end Atalay’s imprisonment, secure his immediate release and enable him to perform his parliamentary duties. The court also ordered Turkey to pay him 32,500 euros in compensation for nonpecuniary damages and adopt measures to ensure that Constitutional Court rulings are implemented and similar violations prevented.

Atalay, a lawyer and human rights defender, was elected to parliament from the southern province of Hatay in May 2023 on the ticket of the Workers’ Party of Turkey (TİP) while serving an 18-year prison sentence in connection with the 2013 Gezi Park protests.

He was convicted in April 2022 of aiding an attempt to overthrow the government over his alleged role in the demonstrations, which began as protests against an urban development project in İstanbul and spread into nationwide anti-government demonstrations.

Despite his election and the accompanying parliamentary immunity, Atalay remained in prison.

The Constitutional Court ruled in October 2023 that his continued imprisonment violated his rights to liberty and political participation. However, an İstanbul court and the Supreme Court of Appeals refused to implement the decision.

The court issued a second ruling in December 2023, finding further rights violations because its previous judgment had not been enforced. The Supreme Court of Appeals again refused to comply and took the unprecedented step of filing criminal complaints against the Constitutional Court judges involved.

Parliament stripped Atalay of his parliamentary status in January 2024 after a Supreme Court of Appeals decision upholding his conviction was read aloud in the chamber. The Constitutional Court subsequently declared the removal legally void, but the decision was not implemented.

In Tuesday’s judgment, the European court criticized the Supreme Court of Appeals for refusing to enforce binding constitutional decisions and departing from its previous legal interpretations without sufficient justification. It also took into account public statements by President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan and other government officials supporting the refusal to implement the rulings.

The court concluded that Atalay’s continued imprisonment served a political purpose beyond any legitimate restriction permitted under the convention, marking a significant development beyond the earlier Constitutional Court findings.

Following the ruling, TİP leader Erkan Baş called on Parliament Speaker Numan Kurtulmuş and other political leaders to ensure Atalay’s immediate release and restoration of his parliamentary status.

Baş said in a post on X that Atalay should be returned to the parliamentary register, released from prison and allowed to take the oath of office.

Atalay had staged a 24-hour hunger strike in October, demanding implementation of the Constitutional Court rulings and the restoration of his right to represent Hatay voters.

Tuesday’s decision was issued by a seven-judge chamber of the European court and is not yet final. Either party may request that the case be referred to the court’s Grand Chamber within three months.