A debate over a meeting between Turkish-German football players Mesut Özil and İlkay Gündoğan and Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan is continuing in Germany.
According to a report by Germany’s Deutsche Welle (DW), many in the country are wondering how much influence his ruling Justice and Development Party (AKP) has in the country.
Because of this meeting Germany is seeing, once again, a lively debate on the integration of its nationals with Turkish roots. It has a similar intensity to one that took place a little more than a year ago, when, in April 2017, 63 percent of Turkish voters in Germany cast their ballots in favor of a constitutional reform and the introduction of a presidential system in Turkey, DW reported.
Now, those divisions have surfaced again, and the role of Erdoğan’s ruling AKP, along with its activities in Germany, faces increasing scrutiny in the process.
“The AKP’s influence must not be underestimated. Compared with the rest of Europe, Germany is the home of the majority of AKP supporters,” Hülya Özkan-Bellut told DW. In her book, “In Erdoğan’s Sights,” the journalist explains why the Turkish president is interested in radicalizing Turkish-Germans. “Every single vote counts, especially now, in an era in which the AKP’s absolute majority is beginning to crumble.”
Therefore, Erdoğan’s public relations networks keep working relentlessly,” says Özkan-Bellut, who also takes a critical view of DİTİB (Turkish-Islamic Union for Religious Affairs) and UETD (Union of European Turkish Democrats). “Those two organizations clearly receive their orders from Erdoğan.”
And they’re having a easy ride, says Özkan-Bellut: After arson attacks on buildings inhabited by Turks, the NSU killings and former SPD politician Thilo Sarrazin’s racially charged views on immigration, Turkish-Germans have become increasingly disenchanted and angry over the last couple of years, feeling marginalized.
“Erdoğan, on the other hand, respects their lifetime achievements and strengthens their self-confidence. He takes advantage of the dissatisfaction felt by a sizeable proportion of Turkish-Germans, thereby winning their hearts,” the journalist explained.
Snap parliamentary and presidential elections will take place in Turkey on June 24. In Germany, some 1,4 million Turks are eligible to vote and will be able to cast their ballots from June 7.
Last summer, the German government stipulated that three months ahead of elections in their home country, foreign politicians are not allowed to stage campaign events in Germany. Erdoğan will, therefore, be unable to campaign on German soil. But he found another way — the ruling AKP immediately posted tweets on all channels that contained images showing German footballers Özil and Gündogan, who have Turkish roots and play for the German national team, with President Erdoğan.
Far-right populists like the Alternative for Germany (AfD), in turn, retaliated by exploiting the photos in order to incite hatred against people of Turkish descent. Turkish officials have been denouncing this for years in talks with their German counterparts, calling for countermeasures.
According to the DW report, however, the focus has now shifted to the issue of how serious German-based institutions like the UETD are when they claim to “see to it that, on the basis of dialogue and cooperation, European Turks become reputable, respected and active citizens in the country they live in” while they maintain ties with the AKP.
“In December 2017, the German government identified, in the wake of a failed coup attempt in Turkey in 2016, “increased attempts by the Turkish state” to exert influence over the more than 3 million people that include the Turkish diaspora and Germans of Turkish origin living within German borders. Those attempts were undertaken by “Turkish diplomatic missions in Germany as well as by institutions like DİTİB and UETD,” said DW.
In addition, the Interior Ministry of the state of North Rhine-Westphalia discovered that “Erdoğan supporters active in social networks regularly call for the denunciation of ‘enemies of the state.’
The “Osmanen Germania” biker gang in particular found itself at the center of attention of those responsible for protecting the constitution. Not only could ties between its leaders and AKP representatives and confidants of Erdoğan be established, but Turkish authorities apparently also support the biker gang “in its ‘fight against terror’ targeting the PKK [Kurdistan Workers’ Party], left-wing extremist Turks, and the Gülen movement.”
“We should not overestimate the AKP’s influence,” argues Yaşar Aydın. The social scientist and Turkey expert doesn’t see any self-reflection or self-criticism emanating from DİTİB, but he points out that Turkish-German Muslims need an institution that organizes religious life, including funerals and Friday prayers. First and foremost, Aydın rejects pigeonholing: “The equation according to which an AKP supporter is not integrated into German society and a critic of Erdogan is does not work.”
In addition, according to the DW report, there had been other attempts to exert influence over Turkish-Germans before the AKP came to power. “We tend to forget that because the party has been governing Turkey for 16 years,” Aydın said. But those attempts would continue if, for example, the Republican People’s Party (CHP) took over.
“Only the means and the rhetoric would be different.” It is perfectly normal, he says, for nations with citizens scattered across other countries to try and establish contact with them in order to build bridges. The important point, however, was that a foreign nation should not interfere with the integration process in Germany. “And in this area the AKP has made many mistakes,” says Aydın.
Journalist Özkan-Bellut told DW that containing the AKP’s influence in Germany is actually very simple. “Germany has to accept Turkish-Germans as equal citizens, and it must make a clear commitment to Turkish-Germans living in the country instead of exploiting them, over and over again, for the purposes of party politics.”
“Erdoğan will be gone one day, but the majority of Turkish-Germans are here to stay,” she points out.
Aydın agrees – the photos that show Özil and Gündoğan with Erdoğan may well be subject to criticism, “but they should not be regarded as an incentive to demonize an entire group of people.”