Four European political leaders say Turkey no longer fulfils the Copenhagen criteria

“Turkey no longer fulfils the Copenhagen criteria, the key that opens the door to EU accession,” wrote Manfred Weber, the chairman of the EPP group in the European Parliament; Guy Verhofstadt, the chairman of the ALDE group in the European Parliament; Dr. Renate Sommer, the permanent EPP group spokeswoman on Turkey; and Alexander Graf Lambsdorff, the vice-president of the European Parliament in a joint article they have written for euobserver.com.

Stating that last July, Turkey went through the painful experience of a military coup, the European political leaders wrote that “However, the reaction of the authorities was disproportionate, leaving the impression that many of the measures taken served the purpose of weakening critics and strengthening President Recep Tayyip Erdogan’s grip on power.”

Listing the Erdoğan regimes persecution and purges, the EP leaders wrote that “15 out of Turkey’s 191 universities are closed by government decree; more than 130 journalists are in jail; 178 media outlets were shut down or put under government control; almost 5000 academics from 112 universities were dismissed during the state of emergency; more than 45,000 detainees are being kept in pre-trial detention (Out of 47,155 detainees, are 10,732 police officers, 7,631 military officers, 2,575 judges and prosecutors, 26,177 civilians and 208 local administrative officials”, interior minister Süleyman Soylu said in late March); more than 110,000 people are being detained as part of investigations into the Gülen movement since the 2016 coup attempt, according to Soylu in a statement on April 3; more than 125,000 civil servants were suspended or fired.”

Reminding that constitutional changes in April 16 referendum “radically weaken both the parliamentary and judicial control of the executive, and lack the safeguards necessary against authoritarian rule,” European leaders stated that “The referendum itself was held during a state of emergency, and against the above-mentioned background of massive intimidation of critical voices and restrictions on media freedom.”

“The OSCE Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights, which observed the referendum, concluded that it was conducted on an uneven playing field, clearly favouring the backers of the reform. The extremely tight result of the referendum (51.4% in favour, with the 3 biggest cities voting against) showed the deep split in Turkish society, which an authoritarian presidential rule will only exacerbate. All of these developments clearly demonstrate that the key basis for accession negotiations has perished, removed by president Erdogan and his AK Party,” wrote Weber, Verhofstadt, Sommer and Lambsdorff.

They wrote that “With the current state of democracy in Turkey, full membership of the EU is no longer realistic,” and added “Instead of continuing the falsehood of accession talks and driving the EU-Turkey relationship towards a dead end, the European Council must look reality in the eye, stop the accession negotiations and put the relationship on new footing… The EU must replace the accession negotiations with a path towards a new association agreement, establishing a deep comprehensive cooperation.”

“This should upgrade the existing relationship and allow for the intensification of political, security and economic cooperation, including an upgraded customs union as proposed by the European Commission last December and also the prospective of visa liberalization, provided the agreed conditions are met. It is, however, critical for both EU and Turkish citizens that this new agreement and the upgraded customs union are firmly tied to respect the European Convention of Human Rights. Turkey is a full member of the Council of Europe, as are all EU member states. These shared values should remain the cornerstone of our deepened economic partnership,” wrote European leaders.

The four political leaders joint article concluded as follow: “In view of the developments in Turkey over the last year, we can no longer afford to carry on with a process that has completely lost its credibility and which risks aggravating the trust between citizens and the EU institutions.

The European Parliament has a specific responsibility in this context. We should make clear to the European Council that, as a parliament, we will only accept the upgrade of the customs union and the visa liberalization agreement as part of and as a first step towards a new association agreement replacing the current accession talks.”

May 2, 2107

Take a second to support SCF on Patreon!